Check Dr: Hulda Clark - she mentions quite a few inventive things to use.
It's on this site somewhere a whole booklet with a lot of her natural recipes.
There are some websites listed below by a couple of wonderful users, who responded to the question: " Natural Make up" (see messages below)
Also, I go to Wholefoods market and they have a some natural products like shampoos and Burt's Bees make-up, soaps and deodorants that may work for you. I use the mosturizer, cleanser, tinted mosturizer and lipstick from Burt's Bees and it feels great to know it does not contain yucky stuff - however I think I am going to try the natural minerals make up line. Everyone seems to love it.
I visited the sites suggested by the respondents to my query and they seem really good... going to decide which ones to try...