Sounds like either you disolved the stones and didn't have them very bad or you just need to do another one. I agree to a point that Science should work with herbal and holistic medicine, but don't down play someone that had a great experience and got results when you didn't.
Sounds like you're disappointed that you didn't achieve the same results.
I'm actually glad to hear this worked so well. I've had many friends that have had their Gall Bladder removed with the same exact symptoms Friday and I think you did the right thing. If she didn't have gall stones, then I guess "SCIENCE" screwed up with my friends and removed a healthy gall bladder for no reason.