Well I can tell you it's not the same girl. They don't even talk the same, their personalities are different, etc.
I'm not asking it to shake your faith Rainy. I hope these people's testimonies are not what you have your faith in anyway.
I was just pointing out that both of them having the same name, First and Middle, and both of them supposedly being asked to change their name by God, especially when Amy seems like a perfectly fine name to me, was quite curious to me. Is that evil?