The SilverGen makes good stuff alright - but you must have the magic touch as you are the first person I have heard who says that it is better than Mesosilver or Utopia-Silver . More typical is the report from one of our herbalist friends and member of our Yahoo group who has made homemade with the same generator you use who reports that she gets much better results with the Utopia-Silver product. That is what we use and try to always keep plenty on hand (right now we have about 8 gallons).