Socal90 yeah,same as. A book probably wouldn't cover what we've been through. I've completely given up on external solutions. The closest I came to having a product work was a soap bar called Wright's that had coal tar in it. It was an antiseptic bar that had a really strong disinfectant smell to it. Have you tried looking at the internal solutions? If you can prevent the smell at the source of the problem,it may go some way to stop your body producing the smell on the outside. Chlorophyll liquid seems to be popular. Champex, pro-m,body mint. Probiotics. There are lots out there. Have a root around the forum.