I'll give the H202 some thought. I have been keeping up with the garlic, and I haven't seen any signs of the problem worsening, so hopefully the garlic is helping. I haven't seen anything suspicious looking since I initially saw something. The animals have all been dewormed and I haven't seen any signs of them having any parasites either, so things are looking up.
I do have to say I'm surprised to see such negativity on what is supposed to be a support forum. I honestly didn't expect that, and I'm disappointed, but I guess that's what you get when you go on any online forum.
For the record... I am still glad I have all of my animals and I love them all, regardless of any germs or illnesses they have.