I have tried every natural cosmetic brand out there. Giving up my makeup and hair products was difficult for me. I have very bad skin and am self conscious about that. I would go to my Organic market ot Health food store and buy "Natural" cosmetics, just to find that they had some of the same preservatives . Methyl-paraben is in almost everything. Sodium Lauryl Sulfate is even in Tom's toothpaste. Benzenes and benzoates are in many too. You have to be careful. I Chose to be weary of such chemicals. I did not buy "Kiss My Face", "Zia", "Ecco Bella", "New Ways", "Aveda" products anymore. After reading Hulda Clark 's books, i realized that rubbing this stuff on my skin would in fact effect my liver and immune system in a negative way.
Aromeleigh has every color under the sun and you can combine shimmers or mattes to make it perfect. I use them a lot. Also, Burt's Bees is very pure. I use their tinted moisturizer and powder. For lips I use Hemp based lipstick from http://www.colorganics.net/. I put Castor oil on my eyelashes.
If you love some makeup product that's not natural, just wear it on special occasions!