CureZone   Log On   Join
Re: The Myth of Alkaline Waters
San2006 Views: 10,150
Published: 11 years ago
This is a reply to # 1,302,142

Re: The Myth of Alkaline Waters

Alkalinity and Hardness are closely related.

Hard Water - Water containing Ca++ and Mg++ cations.
Alkalinity - of water is caused by presence of carbonates, bicarbonates, hydroxides.This is really an expression of buffering capacity.

If water hardness comes from Ca and Mg bicarbonates ( temporary hardness) the water is both Alkaline and Hard.

If water contains Baking Soda ( sodium bicarbonate) or K-bicarbonate, but not enough Ca / Mg, it can be alkaline Soft water.

If water contains Ca and Mg sulphates, chlorides etc (Permanent hardness), but not enought bicarbonate, it is hard water but not alkaline water.

Ca and Mg are essential minerals needed for health. Hence hard water is good. Alkalinity(bicarbonates) is also essential, but not in excess.


1.1 Water hardness defined
Hardness is the term for the calcium or magnesium carbonate
dissolved in water as Ca++, Mg++, and HCO3- (bicarbonate) ions. There
are two measures of water hardness, hardness and alkalinity. Hardness
measures the amount of positive calcium and magnesium ions; alkalinity
the negative bicarbonate ions. Both measures are usually given in
calcium carbonate, i.e. scale, equivalent units (abbreviated as
CaCO3). This means when one unit of scale precipitates out of the
water, hardness and alkalinity measured in CaCO3 units go down by one
unit each.
Alkalinity and hardness levels need not be the same, since the
bicarbonates can be associated with potassium or sodium, and the
calcium or magnesium with chlorides or sulphates. Usually, alkalinity
is less than hardness, although some mineral waters and ion exchange
softened waters rich in sodium or potassium may have higher levels of
Sometimes alkalinity is called "temporary" or "carbonate"
hardness, the difference between hardness and alkalinity, "permanent
hardness", and the hardness itself, "total" or "general" hardness.
This usage is common among aquarium owners, but does not accurately
convey how scaling works.
There are no health hazards associated with water hardness, so
it is not subject to regulation. However, hard water causes scale, as
well as the scumming and reduced lathering of soaps. Very soft waters,
exposed to air or heat, become acidic and corrosive, and can harshen
the taste of vegetables, tea, or coffee. So, several countries
including the US, UK, Canada, and Germany have issued non-binding
recommended hardness ranges. These are usually aroung 80 to 100mg/l
hardness and 50 to 60 mg/l alkalinity, figures calculated to minimize
the combined cost of scaling and corrosion in municipal piping and
domestic hotwater systems. The levels required for taste, or for low
maintenance steam boiler, spa, or aquarium operation, can be quite
Water boards call waters in the recommended range "neutral,"
those below the recommended range are called "moderately soft," below
half the range, "very soft," above the range "moderately hard", and
above twice the range "very hard." However, the exact ranges referred
to by these names varies, and one should always get the exact water


Printer-friendly version of this page Email this message to a friend
Alert Moderators
Report Spam or bad message  Alert Moderators on This GOOD Message

This Forum message belongs to a larger discussion thread. See the complete thread below. You can reply to this message!


Donate to CureZone

CureZone Newsletter is distributed in partnership with

Contact Us - Advertise - Stats

Copyright 1999 - 2019

0.906 sec, (2)