Slider, your argument is the most cogent one I have seen against the liver flush. I used to be a believer on the basis of what people like Andreas Moritz said, even though I never got permanent relief from Liver Flushing - I kept on doing it, thinking that the next flush would be the last. Like you I think it's pretty strange that we hardly ever hear of anyone flushing clean when Andreas supposedly did so after just 12 flushes or something. I'm only 18 so I should, in theory, have a fairly clean liver anyway - yet I've already done at least as many LFs as Andreas claimed to do and I still get just as many stones. I wish I could get to the bottom of this. I don't believe the Liver Flush is complete quackery but I don't think it works in the way they claim either.