CureZone
Old Format -> CureZone.INFO
Image Embedded Catholic Bishops Take on Obama
  • Image Embedded Catholic Bishops Take on Obama   InCharge   4y  266  
    This is my avatar. Click here to see my profile.
    InCharge
    Date: 4/23/2012 10:14:58 AM   ( 4y ago )   Hits:   266

    The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops has taken a bold stand for religious freedom. In a recent statement, titled “Our First, Most Cherished Liberty,” the bishops call for repeal of contraception coverage mandated by the Department of Health and Human Services. The clarified position sets up a dramatic confrontation with the Obama administration—and would, if the bishops prevail, help preserve the religious liberty of all Americans.

    Barack Obama

    Barack Obama listens to a question from a guests attending the Health Care Summit.

     

    The HHS mandate requires employers to provide insurance coverage for contraception and sterilization services. It is, according to the bishops, an “unjust law.” They write: “It cannot be obeyed and therefore one does not seek relief from it, but rather its repeal.”

    The statement is a rebuke of President Obama and the so-called accommodation his administration proposed in February. It also raises the stakes between the president and the leaders of America’s Catholic Church.

    The bishops call on Catholics in America, “in solidarity with our fellow citizens,” not to obey the law. They implicitly compare the HHS regulation to a segregation-era statute, and even cite Martin Luther King Jr.’s “Letter from a Birmingham Jail.” In a not-so-subtle manner, the bishops tell the Obama administration that they are willing to go to prison rather than comply with the mandate’s provisions.

    In doing so, the bishops are ruling out the possibility of a compromise that might preserve the mandate by expanding possible conscience exemptions from it. Most discussion had been over how far the religious liberty exemption should extend—but with the bishops calling for repeal, that all could change.

     

    The Obama administration was not against an exemption per se, it just wanted a narrow one that only covered church employees serving members of their own faith with jobs pertaining to the inculcation of religious belief. The Catholic bishops, it seemed, wanted a more robust exemption that covered institutions of faith, including hospitals, universities, and other social service providers.
    Now the bishops have made clear that the contraception mandate must be rescinded, because, in their view, even a more expansive exemption cannot sufficiently protect religious freedom.
    The bishops did not have to take this route, but all those who cherish religious liberty should be glad they did. If the bishops settled for a more expansive accommodation, they might have been able to get an exemption for their hospitals and universities (including my own, Notre Dame). That would have been the easy way to “preserve” religious liberty while also retaining the mandate.
    But what, then, would the bishops have said to business owners who likely would not have been covered by a more expansive exemption? How could church leaders say that it’s wrong for church institutions to pay for contraception and abortifacients, but that Catholic business owners must cover these costs?
    The exemption approach might have allowed the bishops to secure religious liberty for their institutions, but not for all their followers. That would have been a failure of moral authority and political strength to protect the common good.
    To their credit, the bishops appear to understand this and are now willing to lead the battle to preserve religious liberty for all, Catholics and non-Catholics, church institutions and private employers.
    But it won’t be without confrontation. This statement from the bishops sets up a dramatic showdown between the leaders of the Catholic Church and the Obama administration, a confrontation that may not be good for either side. It is hard to see what middle ground exists, or even if it does.
    The Constitution was designed to prevent such fundamental clashes between church and state. Perhaps the best way out of this thicket would be for the Supreme Court to step in and stop it from happening. Striking down the contraception mandate would avert the disastrous situation of the president sending bishops to jail for being faithful witnesses to their religious convictions. 
    Vincent Phillip Muñoz, Tocqueville associate professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame and associate professor of law at University of Notre Dame School of Law, is author of God and the Founders: Madison, Washington, and Jefferson

     

    http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/catholic-bishops-take-obama_640569.html

     
    Printer-friendly version of this page Email this message to a friend
    Alert Moderators
    Report Spam or bad message  Alert Moderators on This GOOD Message
  • How can I view entire discussion thread on a single page?

    How can I expand all forum messages on a single forum page?


     

    Donate to CureZone


    Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Spam Policy - Disclaimer - Guidelines & Rules

    CureZone Newsletter is distributed in partnership with www.netatlantic.com


    Contact Us - About - Advertise - Stats

    Copyright 1999 - 2016  www.curezone.org

    0.117 sec, (4)

    ”I Cured My Candida”
    Eliminate Candida Symptoms Within Hours!


    Natural Cancer Remedies


    Hormonal Imbalance Webinar
    Everything You Need for Natural Solutions for Hormonal Imba...


    Cure Type 2 Diabetes

    Simple, 3-step natural approach heals diabetes within a month. ...


    Weight Loss Fast & Easy
    Drop pounds daily drinking antioxidant detox ionized water whi...



    Internal Organ Cleanser
    Millions of antioxidant ions clean and detoxify your body curi...


    Proven medical anti-diabetic benefits
    Electrolyzed drinking water significantly reduce...


    Proven medical anti-diabetic benefits
    Electrolyzed drinking water significantly reduce...


    99.999% Pure Silver
    Makes the Purest Colloidal Silver. Order Your Immune System Boost ...


    Purest Body Products
    No solvents, no heavy metals, organic, vegan, no animal testing


    Hulda Clark Cleanses
    Wormwood, Clove, Clarkia, Turmeric, Epsom Salt, Uva Ursi, Goldenr...



    Anti Diabetic Effect
    Improves blood glucose tolerance


    Cure Arthritis Joint Pain
    Imagine life without joint pain


    Proven Parasite Diet
    The Only Legitimate Diet for Destroying Parasites in 30 Days or L...


    Free Shipping Over $40 +15% Off Colloidal Silver
    Advanced Colloidal Silver-Mankind’s o...


    Anti Diabetic Effect
    Improves blood glucose tolerance


    Pure High PPM Antioxidants
    Bring your body back to perfections with Pure Colloidal Sil...


    Alkaline Water Ionizers
    Cure Common Diseases And Detoxify Your Body Resulting In Natur...



    The Tesla Shield™
    Transformational Technology For Mind Body And Soul.


    Hulda Clark ParaZapper
    See why these are the worlds best zappers


    Cancer’s Natural Enemy
    The eBook about a proven natural remedy for cancer which has wo...


    Lugol’s Iodine Free S&H
    J.Crow’s® Lugol’s Iodine Solution. Restore lost reserves.


    Be a Man Again!
    Recover Your Manhood with PriMale.


    Best Candida Cure
    The only clinically proven candida cure with a 100%guarantee


    Juice Fasting Made Easy
    Organic 9 day juice fasting kit. Heals the body, removes toxin...


    longevity peptides for researchers
    worldwide delivery


    -Orp Oxygen Cures Cancer
    Medical Research proves an abundance of Oxygen -ORP benefits ...


    Cancer Cure & Prevention
    Medical Research proves an abundance of Oxygen -ORP benefits ...


    Cancer Cure & Prevention
    Medical Research proves an abundance of Oxygen -ORP benefits ...


    Boost Your Immunity System
    Increase Oxygen to your cells & boost the bodies Immune Sys...


    Your Ad Here