Well, I understand that you are taking his tonic and want to remain upbeat and supportive, I am simply pointing out the fact that not too long ago Charlie placed his liver tonic recipe on curezone where anyone could take that information and run with it, as he would say. He claims now that it is irresponsible to give out this recipe because it is too dangerous and must be monitored by the most talented of ALL herbalists, Charlie Benhauser.
This puts fear into people. Furthermore, he has been putting down other recipes of herbal tonics claiming too that they are irresponsible. It appears that only Charlie Benhauser is capable of administering herbs to all people and we lowly non-herbalists are incapable of selecting herbal remedies for ourselves.
In addition, I think his goal is to scare people enough that they will be afraid to go out and make a tonic on their own and this is not the spirit of CUREZONE, this website is here for people to learn to help themselves and share information.
While I am sure his liver tonic along with consultations is convenient and much easier than trying to make it own your own, I don't see why he needs to frighten people into believing they can't experiment, especially for those who are in a financial bind and can't afford to risk it, or prefer to know what they are injesting, the latter I think is a big reason why many won't be interested in buying his tonic.